Click here to return to Bulletin Board's Home Page    Click here for help   Search the bulletin board



PRK or Lasik? Which is better?


Table of Contents
.....................................................................................................................

PRK or Lasik? Which is better?, nora - miami beach, FL, 10/13/2000
PRK versus LASIK, William B. Trattler, MD Miami, FL 10/13/2000, (#1)

.....................................................................................................................

"PRK or Lasik? Which is better?"
Posted by nora - miami beach, FL on 09:53:56 10/13/2000
Include Original
Message on Reply
Hello: I have -8.0 in my right eye and -7.5 in my left. I have been considering PRK but have read that for high myopia the risks for "after glare" and eventual vision loss are higher.

On the other hand, I have heard that PRK is safer as there is no cut to the cornea.

Please advise....

Click to go to Table of Contents

1. "PRK versus LASIK"
Posted by William B. Trattler, MD on 18:19:32 10/13/2000
Include Original
Message on Reply
Both PRK and LASIK are very effective surgeries for patients with myopia. Both procedures have their advantages and disadvantages. As well, they both have their particular risks.
For a patient with 8 diopters of myopia, the advantage of LASIK is that the recovery can be within hours. It is not uncommon for patients to have LASIK on both eyes and the next day be able to drive a car. Generally, patients will have minimal to no discomfort. With PRK, generally only one eye is done at a time. With each eye, there is a 3 to 5 day recovery period. As well, there is also an extended healing period which can last for days to weeks as the corneal surface heals. During the initial 3 days after PRK, there is some discomfort and photosensitivity, and basically you would need to rest at home as the eye healed.
As for risks - both procedures have risks of infections - although the risk for infection is slightly higher with PRK due to the extended healing process. With LASIK, there are some risks of flap problems - but most of these problems if they do occur either do not effect vision, or can be fixed. With PRK, the biggest risk is corneal haze, which can occur months after the procedure. The haze can affect vision occasionally, and the risk of developing haze is related to the level of myopia. As well, ultraviolet light exposure can exacerbate the haze, so it is important to wear UV-protective sunglasses after PRK. In general for a person with 8 diopters of myopia, the risk of visually-significant haze is on the very low side.
In summary - there are risks to both, and advantages to both. The reason that LASIK has become so popular is because it can seem to many people like a miracle - as the visual recovery is so fast. But people who get PRK also get excellent visual results.
One of the keys when considering these procedures is to find a highly qualifed refractive surgeon who can carefully discuss your options. Make sure that you get a chance to talk with the potential surgeons, as they are the one's that are best able to discuss all of the advanatages and disadvantages of each.
I am in practice in South Miami/Kendall at Baptist Hospital, and would be happy to answer any specific questions that you might have regarding PRK or LASIK.

Best of luck

Bill Trattler, MD
Miami, FL
ext 1200

Click to go to Table of Contents



If you encounter any problems with the bulletin board, please notify the
About Us           Bulletin Board           Doctor Directory           Contact Us

The information contained here on Ask Lasik Doctors should be used for informational purposes only. Please read the disclaimer.